Relatedly: I'd been meaning to mention I finally saw Inception a few weeks ago, months after everyone else did, and I was entirely underwhelmed. The action scenes were dull and overlong (except the hallway one), DiCaprio's put his faith in his acting ability entirely into his frowny forehead and all the secrets he was trying desperately to convince us he was keeping were all obvious from the start.
And I thought the ending was much simpler than people seemed to try to convince themselves of. What's important about the top was not that it stopped spinning but that he stopped watching it --- the top is Mal's totem, not his, his totem has become something different: he know that in a dream he can't see his children's faces. He gives up Mal's idea of reality/unreality and decides, no, this is what reality is. Which is not to say that there is no possibility that he could dream up his children's faces, but that he has accepted the word "reality" to mean this: the world in which I can see my children's faces. He's decided reality means a sort of togetherness, a reconciliation, which is ultimately the same for cilian murphy or watanabe. There will always be the nagging question of whether any world is real (hence the camera cutting away before it could be proven one way or another), but he's decided to hold on to this reconciliation as truth. And as the credits roll we're supposed to take that with us as we wake up from the dream of the movie.
(of course there's no proof that dicaprio hasn't been sleeping for the whole movie. but as there's no proof for or against this, it's just not an interesting theory. Any movie could be a dream, what does that add to our understanding of it?)
(Just as we're supposed to believe in The Usual Suspects, Stephen, that Verbal isn't making up the entire narrative, but only changing names as he sees fit. What we see is an objective recounting of the narrative — If it had been a subjective account then we'd more easily believe what he was trying to get Palminteri to believe, that Gabriel Byrne is Kaiser Soze. No one believed that Gabriel Byrne was Kaiser Soze, it just didn't fit with the story as presented on-screen. Though it might fit with a verbal recounting of it (which was the point). So we see that Soze is just arrogant enough to give a 100% factual recounting of events, only changing small things like the name of his lawyer (just in case), secure in his knowledge that it will be misinterpreted.)
September 25 2010, 22:48:04 UTC 1 year ago
September 26 2010, 02:36:14 UTC 1 year ago
(I'm such a naive reader, such a naive payer-of attention; it took you to note that the important thing is not what the lead stops watching but THAT the lead stops watching)
I haven't seen it, and don't know that I will. Certainly if I do, the hallway sequence, probably all the Gordon-Levitt of it, will be what-for.
September 26 2010, 04:22:11 UTC 1 year ago
September 26 2010, 09:00:26 UTC 1 year ago
Him and Juno were so out of place they were frequently more interesting than the place.
September 26 2010, 02:52:51 UTC 1 year ago
September 26 2010, 04:21:51 UTC 1 year ago
September 27 2010, 12:04:09 UTC 1 year ago
are dreams about thought or about perception
September 27 2010, 23:05:37 UTC 1 year ago Edited: September 27 2010, 23:06:19 UTC
I mean only that in dream logic time is undone but meaning remains stubbornly, inexplicably intact. If it were a really a movie about dreams, I think it would have had better ways of dealing with time than mere measurement. But then, I've never dreamed a clock that wasn't broken.
I don't know if my dreams matter to anyone when my eyes are open. I'll post one sometime if you like.
October 2 2010, 22:05:13 UTC 1 year ago
Two weeks ago I dreamed that I was watching a young boy, probably ten, identified as the son of a friend of my mother's that I haven't seen in maybe fifteen years, but in the dream he was ten or so and still looked up to me. It was one of those run-down two-story houses you see in west orange nj, the kind with random rickety fire escapes, houses that look like no one has owned in decades but maybe squatters or drug dealers. Well the boy was on a walkway coming back to the window of the fire escape and I was watching from the window. And I thought, he's going to fall. And so he did, and banged against the rungs of the ladder about halfway down then hit the ground. And I went down to him and I called the ambulance and sat with him and took him back upstairs. He seemed to be fine though I encouraged him not to move, thought he might have cracked a rib or something broken inside. It was some time and no ambulance and when I did hear something pull up outside it was a van for the downstairs neighbors and they set up a family party on the lawn, trays of nice spanish food in lines, people everywhere. When the boy's mother came home she asked me why I called the ambulance, who has money to pay for an ambulance. she told me to go down and get some food.
September 26 2010, 16:55:01 UTC 1 year ago
Anyway, rewatch the movie sometime thinking in terms of auto-inception: DiCaprio was able to convince his wife of something, though there was blowback, but to heal the damage he attempted to incept himself. Listen closely to all dialogue about how inception works - e.g. having the same things repeated on different levels. He didn't just choose beauty over truth in a state of uncertainty, he chose beauty over truth by calculation, but realizing that the choice could only count if he systematically eliminated all uncertainty. He performed brain surgery on himself using a semi-lucid dream. And even if I'm wrong that's a much more interesting movie. Just like I should be paid to remake The Time Traveler's Wife.
September 26 2010, 20:46:42 UTC 1 year ago
But an important plot point is that inception is difficult to perform because you're performing it on another person. auto-inception would be, like, having an idea.
not saying it wouldn't be more interesting.
start making plots again.
September 27 2010, 06:03:02 UTC 1 year ago
September 27 2010, 06:47:26 UTC 1 year ago
just sayin'
September 27 2010, 16:26:13 UTC 1 year ago